Taylor Swift vs Beyoncé

19 albumsby simanUpdated 27 July 2026Other

This order was decided by the TakeRank community: 168 head-to-head votes across 19 albums, settled with an Elo rating.

  1. 1
    Fearless (Taylor’s Version)
    Fearless (Taylor’s Version)

    Taylor Swift (2021)

    1099
    11 votes
  2. 2
    Midnights
    Midnights

    Taylor Swift (2022)

    1074
    11 votes
  3. 3
    THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT
    THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT

    Taylor Swift (2024)

    1048
    11 votes
  4. 4
    Red (Taylor’s Version)
    Red (Taylor’s Version)

    Taylor Swift (2021)

    1047
    11 votes
  5. 5
    I Am… Sasha Fierce
    I Am… Sasha Fierce

    Beyoncé (2008)

    1036
    6 votes
  6. 6
    B’Day
    B’Day

    Beyoncé (2006)

    1033
    6 votes
  7. 7
    1989 (Taylor’s Version)
    1989 (Taylor’s Version)

    Taylor Swift (2023)

    1019
    11 votes
  8. 8
    Lover
    Lover

    Taylor Swift (2019)

    1016
    11 votes
  9. 9
    Dangerously in Love
    Dangerously in Love

    Beyoncé (2003)

    1005
    6 votes
  10. 10
    Lemonade
    Lemonade

    Beyoncé (2016)

    999
    6 votes
  11. 11
    Speak Now (Taylor’s Version)
    Speak Now (Taylor’s Version)

    Taylor Swift (2023)

    993
    12 votes
  12. 12
    reputation
    reputation

    Taylor Swift (2017)

    990
    11 votes
  13. 13
    COWBOY CARTER
    COWBOY CARTER

    Beyoncé (2024)

    968
    6 votes
  14. 14
    BEYONCÉ
    BEYONCÉ

    Beyoncé (2013)

    962
    6 votes
  15. 15
    evermore
    evermore

    Taylor Swift (2020)

    953
    11 votes
  16. 16
    RENAISSANCE
    RENAISSANCE

    Beyoncé (2022)

    953
    5 votes
  17. 17
    The Life of a Showgirl
    The Life of a Showgirl

    Taylor Swift (2025)

    944
    8 votes
  18. 18
    folklore
    folklore

    Taylor Swift (2020)

    936
    10 votes
  19. 19
    Taylor Swift
    Taylor Swift

    Taylor Swift (2006)

    924
    9 votes