AFI

AFI Albums Ranked

Every AFI album ranked worst to best by the fans who voted, one head-to-head matchup at a time. Their #1: Sing the Sorrow.

punkalternative rockpunk rockrockalternativeemo

Ranked by fans

The Art of Drowning

The Art of Drowning

2000

110775% won

2ND16 votes
Sing the Sorrow

Sing the Sorrow

2003

1189100% won

1ST16 votes
Black Sails in the Sunset

Black Sails in the Sunset

1999

110581% won

3RD16 votes
  1. 4
    DECEMBERUNDERGROUND

    DECEMBERUNDERGROUND

    2006

    1082

    16 votes - 75% won

    Amazon MusicVinyl
  2. 5
    Crash Love

    Crash Love

    2009

    974

    16 votes - 50% won

    Amazon MusicVinyl
  3. 6
    AFI (The Blood Album)

    AFI (The Blood Album)

    2017

    957

    16 votes - 38% won

    Amazon MusicVinyl
  4. 7
    Shut Your Mouth and Open Your Eyes

    Shut Your Mouth and Open Your Eyes

    1997

    951

    16 votes - 31% won

    SpotifyAppleDeezerAmazon MusicVinyl
  5. 8
    Bodies

    Bodies

    2021

    941

    16 votes - 38% won

    Amazon MusicVinyl
  6. 9
    Very Proud of Ya

    Very Proud of Ya

    1996

    935

    16 votes - 25% won

    Amazon MusicVinyl
  7. 10
    Silver Bleeds the Black Sun…

    Silver Bleeds the Black Sun…

    2025

    934

    16 votes - 38% won

    Amazon MusicVinyl
  8. 11
    Burials

    Burials

    2013

    925

    16 votes - 31% won

    Amazon MusicVinyl
  9. 12
    Answer That and Stay Fashionable

    Answer That and Stay Fashionable

    1995

    900

    16 votes - 19% won

    Amazon MusicVinyl
albums
12albums
fans voting
2fans voting
votes
226votes
avg rating
1000avg rating

Top Songs

  1. 1
    Sing the Sorrow

    The Great Disappointment

    Sing the Sorrow
    1170

    7 votes

  2. 2
    DECEMBERUNDERGROUND

    37mm

    DECEMBERUNDERGROUND
    1115

    7 votes

  3. 3
    Crash Love

    End Transmission

    Crash Love
    1110

    2 votes

  4. 4
    The Art of Drowning

    The Lost Souls

    The Art of Drowning
    1108

    2 votes

  5. 5
    Black Sails in the Sunset

    God Called In Sick Today / Midnight Sun

    Black Sails in the Sunset
    1103

    2 votes

  6. 6
    Very Proud of Ya

    This Secret Ninja

    Very Proud of Ya
    1095

    2 votes

  7. 7
    Sing the Sorrow

    Bleed Black

    Sing the Sorrow
    1094

    7 votes

  8. 8
    The Art of Drowning

    Ever and a Day

    The Art of Drowning
    1079

    2 votes

  9. 9
    Crash Love

    Beautiful Thieves

    Crash Love
    1078

    2 votes

  10. 10
    Burials

    I Hope You Suffer

    Burials
    1078

    2 votes

Rank AFI's albums

Vote on head-to-head matchups and see where your ranking agrees with the fans.

START RANKING

AFI albums: your questions

What is AFI's best album?
Sing the Sorrow (2003) is AFI's #1 album on TakeRank, winning 100% of its 16 head-to-head matchups.
What is AFI's most underrated album?
DECEMBERUNDERGROUND (2006) sits at #4 but wins 75% of its matchups, the best record of any AFI album outside their top three.
How many albums has AFI released?
AFI has released 12 studio albums, from Answer That and Stay Fashionable (1995) to Silver Bleeds the Black Sun… (2025).

Vinyl links go to Amazon, and Amazon Music links open Amazon's free trial of Music Unlimited. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.