What is AFI's best album?

Sing the Sorrow (2003) is AFI's #1 album on TakeRank, winning 100% of its 16 head-to-head matchups.

What is AFI's most underrated album?

DECEMBERUNDERGROUND (2006) sits at #4 but wins 75% of its matchups, the best record of any AFI album outside their top three.

AFI has released 12 studio albums, from Answer That and Stay Fashionable (1995) to Silver Bleeds the Black Sun… (2025).

Every AFI album ranked worst to best by the fans who voted, one head-to-head matchup at a time. Their #1: Sing the Sorrow.

2000

110775% won

2003

1189100% won

1999

110581% won

1
The Great Disappointment
Sing the Sorrow
1145
5 votes
2
37mm
DECEMBERUNDERGROUND
1118
5 votes
3
Bleed Black
Sing the Sorrow
1063
5 votes
4
Synesthesia
Sing the Sorrow
1041
5 votes
5
Now the World / [The Spoken Word] / This Time Imperfect
Sing the Sorrow
1037
5 votes
6
The Missing Frame
DECEMBERUNDERGROUND
1031
5 votes
7
The Killing Lights
DECEMBERUNDERGROUND
1015
6 votes
8
Dancing Through Sunday
Sing the Sorrow
1004
5 votes
9
The Leaving Song, Part II
Sing the Sorrow
1002
5 votes
10
This Celluloid Dream
Sing the Sorrow
997
5 votes

Vote on head-to-head matchups and see where your ranking agrees with the fans.

What is AFI's best album?: Sing the Sorrow (2003) is AFI's #1 album on TakeRank, winning 100% of its 16 head-to-head matchups.
What is AFI's most underrated album?: DECEMBERUNDERGROUND (2006) sits at #4 but wins 75% of its matchups, the best record of any AFI album outside their top three.
How many albums has AFI released?: AFI has released 12 studio albums, from Answer That and Stay Fashionable (1995) to Silver Bleeds the Black Sun… (2025).